Milk +
Commodity
Good priceMilk + by Commodity ranks among the best perfumes for women .This top sweets fragrance blends Amber, Cedar, Marshmallow, Milk, Musk, Woody Notes notes with sweets, woods & mosses, musk, amber and animalic accords, earning high praise in our perfume review community. Milk + excels as one of the best perfumes for winter or fall, shining during day wear. Our PerfumeRates community ranks Milk + as a leading sweets fragrance for women, a must-try from Commodity's top perfume brands. Dive into the best perfume reviews, explore top women's fragrances, and discover cheap perfume deals on PerfumeRates!
Votes
spring71
summer24
fall165
winter170
day283
night147
Longevity(166)
enduringlongmoderateshortfaint
Sillage(168)
powerfulstrongsoftclose
Price value(151)
excellentgoodfaircostlynot worthy
female (114)
unisex (78)
male (8)
57%
39%
4%
Ocassions
Main accords
All ocassions
Notes
Amber
Cedar
Marshmallow
Milk
Musk
Woody Notes
Smells almost identical to Amika Perk Up dry shampoo in the dry down.
This smells so much like by the fireplace by replica, just no smokiness and chestnut.
What a comforting hug smells like. I usually don't expect much from perfumes that can be found at shopping malls because they can be generic, but this one stands out. Photorealistic fluffy milk, but no marshmallow detected. Very warm and light. Milk- is unapologetically lactonic, unlike most other milk perfumes that add vanilla or sweet notes to appeal to the masses. I feel like people don't talk enough about the amber and woody notes cuz they the key factors in this composition that make the milkiness so deliciously real. Would've consider making this my signature scent had it not turn sour like spoiled milk on my skin. My mum tried this and it smells heavenly, so please test before buy. Suitable for colder seasons, though I can't decide if this is a good office perfume or not. Overall 9/10, it's worth the hype! I would encourage everyone to try this out once on their fragrance journey. Update: gave this another try today along with Milk and apparently my skin chem has changed. This now smell purely like marshmallows without the plasticky sweetness from Milk. Haven't try Milk+ yet but now I'm intrigued. This one is still my favourite out of the three.
Just like the milk expressive, this is awful. Though, this is less awful because it is a watered down version of the other perfume. It smells like the worst, cheapest wax cashmere musk woods candle in the world. I wanted to love this so bad. I'm happy for others if they love this.
I was hoping for more milk and woods. On my skin, it's just sugar (marshmallow I guess). And it is not as soft as I would expect from Personal scent. Will try it more and see what happens. EDIT: Now, that I have examined all three versions better, I can really sense the musk here. At least comparing to Expressive and Bold version. Since marshmallow is so much more present in Expressive and especially in Bold version, I could actually say that I can sense the milk in this one the most. It is very warm, milky musk. Very beautiful.